Minority Studies

Get Homicide Law Reform, Gender and the Provocation Defence: A PDF

By Kate Fitz-Gibbon

ISBN-10: 113735755X

ISBN-13: 9781137357557

ISBN-10: 1349470805

ISBN-13: 9781349470808

This ebook seriously examines the operation of the partial defence of provocation in more than a few comparative foreign jurisdictions. Centrally considering conceptual questions of gender, justice and the position of denial within the legal justice process, Fitz-Gibbon explores the divergent ways taken to reforming the legislation of provocation.

Show description

Read or Download Homicide Law Reform, Gender and the Provocation Defence: A Comparative Perspective PDF

Best minority studies books

Download e-book for iPad: A World of Its Own: Race, Labor, and Citrus in the Making of by Matt Garcia

Tracing the heritage of intercultural fight and cooperation within the citrus belt of higher la, Matt Garcia explores the social and cultural forces that helped make the town the expansive and assorted city that it really is at the present time. because the citrus-growing areas of the San Gabriel and Pomona Valleys in jap la County increased in the course of the early 20th century, the rural there built alongside segregated traces, essentially among white landowners and Mexican and Asian employees.

Download PDF by Frances Negrón-Muntaner: None of the Above: Puerto Ricans in the Global Era (New

Not one of the Above is a cutting-edge quantity approximately present debates concerning Puerto Rico and Puerto Ricans, either within the usa and at the Island. The name at the same time refers back to the result of a non-binding 1998 plebiscite held to figure out the Island's political prestige, the ambiguities that experience traditionally characterised Puerto Rican political supplier, and the complexities of Puerto Rican ethnic, nationwide, and cultural identifications.

New PDF release: Radicals Against Race: Black Activism and Cultural Politics

This booklet interrogates the guidelines and practices of the hot Beacon Circle's activists as really good components within the fast-changing scene of up to date radical politics. Highlighting how biography and self illustration have vital cultural, theoretical and political implications, Alleyne succeeds in making an unique contribution to a becoming literature on autobiography as a wealthy source for figuring out social and political concept.

Download e-book for iPad: Immigration and Race: New Challenges for American Democracy by Professor Gerald D. Jaynes

A variety of insights approximately conflicts and pageant, important to those that formulate immigration regulations. The insights are derived from the paintings of authors corresponding to Frank D. Bean, Thomas E. Cavanagh, John A. Garcia, Peter H. Schuck, Wendy Zimmerman, and extra.

Additional resources for Homicide Law Reform, Gender and the Provocation Defence: A Comparative Perspective

Example text

It is not a mitigating circumstance for a husband who either kills or assaults their spouse 42 Homicide Law Reform, Gender and the Provocation Defence that their actions were a response to being advised by their spouse of a decision to end their relationship . . Married women have the right to choose their own destiny. Significant punishments will be imposed upon those who inflict violence on them for exercising that right. (Maglovski, per Beech-Jones J at 81–91) The failed use of the provocation defence in these two cases, alongside the clear condemnation provided by each of the judges in sentencing, arguably indicates a shift that has occurred in relation to the acceptance of provocation in cases where the provoked actions of the victim need to be read and understood using a cultural lens.

He then woke during the night and discovered Morton and Wilkins having sex. In response Cranston claimed to have lost his self-control during which he killed his wife with a single stab wound to the heart and killed Wilkins with multiple wounds. In his ‘999’ call to the police immediately afterwards he stated, ‘Yes, it is me. I found my wife and one of my best friends shagging and I lost my rag and I just stabbed them’ (as cited in Hodge, 2009). Over the course of the seven-day trial, Cranston gave evidence to the jury that upon discovering his wife and friend having sex he was ‘just dumbstruck.

In doing so, it challenges the current applicability of the defence given its propensity to uphold outdated notions of male honour, women as property and the legitimisation of violence against the homosexual or cultured ‘other’. Adultery and ‘crimes of passion’ Central to the historical foundations of the provocation defence is the notion of women as property and the need to respond to an act of adultery in a way that restores honour to a male scorned. As noted previously, in the 17th century and after (following the 1707 decision in Mawgridge), adultery was established as one of four contexts to which the provocation defence applied to reduce what would otherwise be murder to manslaughter.

Download PDF sample

Homicide Law Reform, Gender and the Provocation Defence: A Comparative Perspective by Kate Fitz-Gibbon


by Brian
4.0

Rated 4.83 of 5 – based on 14 votes